CLEANING > REVIEWS
clean&greenliving
2024's Top Laundry Detergent Sheets, Tested and Ranked
By Veda S.
January 12th, 2024
Our team reveals the top-performing brands in the competitive laundry detergent sheet market.
There’s been a new exciting innovation in the laundry world that’s disrupting the industry.
This new exciting innovation is called Laundry Detergent Sheets.
These laundry sheets are small thin sheets of material that are packed with pre-measured concentration of detergent and dissolve in the washing machine, eliminating the need to measure and pour out liquid detergent.
Laundry detergent sheets are exploding in popularity as they’re eco-friendly, space-saving, use plastic-free packaging and are completely mess-free (no more blue goo).
Due to their popularity, we’ve seen many new laundry detergent sheet brands pop up, including some that don’t meet the highest standards.
That’s why our team of editors decided to put laundry detergent sheets from 14 different brands to the test, and narrowed down to the top 4 brands that were able to remove stains the best.
Do Laundry Detergent Sheets really work?
From our testing we found that some brands actually clean and remove stains better than both liquid and pod detergent.
However this depends on the ingredients used in the Laundry Sheet and we're looking for powerful cleaning ability without the use of harsh, skin-irritating chemicals.
The ingredients used from brand to brand seemed to be completely different, which meant the cleaning power was vastly different as well.
Do they work with all washing machines?
Yes, laundry detergent sheets work with all types of washing machines including top loading, front loading, or a high efficiency (HE) machine - they all work.
Avoid These Ingredients - 100%
Parabens: These are used as preservatives, but they've been linked to hormonal disruption in numerous studies.
Phosphates: These are often used in laundry detergents to soften water and improve cleaning, but they can be harmful to aquatic life when they enter rivers and lakes.
Optical Brighteners: These can make clothes appear whiter and brighter, but they don't actually clean your clothes. They can also be allergenic and are not readily biodegradable
Top 4 Laundry Detergent Sheets of 2024 Tested and Ranked
Our team of editors analyzed 18 laundry detergent sheets from 14 different brands, tackling many different stains and operating our washing machines for 2 days.
The evaluation criteria for each detergent sheet included its ability in removing 20 usual stains, restoring the original whiteness of a standard pre-stained fabric swatch, and its speed and thoroughness of dissolution in water, and its scent profile. We also carefully inspected the labels on these detergent sheets to ensure they had proper safety warnings and clear instructions.
Cleaning Ability: A+
Pros:
Best results out of all products tested in removing tough stains and making clothes look fresh and clean again (completely removed red wine, coffee, grass).
Formulated with powerful stain busting but clean ingredients
Safe for whites, colors, and delicates
Clean ingredients & non-toxic
Available in 3 unique, delightful scents that smell amazing
Dissolves easily and no residue left after wash
30 day satisfaction guarantee
Free shipping on all orders
Cons:
They aren’t sold in retail stores (only available via their online website or Amazon)
Only available for purchase in the USA
Shop Frey Sheets
The Frey Laundry Detergent Sheets wowed our whole team - it was the top overall scorer by a long shot.
It was able to remove the toughest of stains including coffee, red wine, dirt and even grass.
The cleaning power of these sheets was unmatched, likely due to their use of the powerful naturally derived ingredients which are safe and non-toxic but still powerful enough to break down tiny particles on your clothes.
Frey’s Laundry Detergent Sheets were also very quick to dissolve in both hot and cold water and left no residue. Our team particularly loved the packaging - the instructions are very clear so there's little guesswork when deciding the dosage for each load.
Outside of the cleaning power and clean ingredients, we absolutely fell in love with their scents! All of the other laundry detergent sheets were “Fresh Linen” and smelled pretty generic and the same but Frey was an absolute stand out with their 3 unique scents of Bergamot Beach, Cedar Grove, and Jasmine Meadow.
The only drawback is that Frey’s Laundry Detergent Sheets are currently exclusively sold online through their official website and not available in store. However they offer a money-back guarantee which not all other brands have.
Frey is currently offering savings up to 40% for a limited time. No coupon code needed.
Shop Frey Sheets
2
EC30: Runner-Up
2
Cleaning Ability: A-
Pros:
Good at removing tough stains like coffee but didn't remove red wine as well as Frey
Suitable for all machines and temps
Safe for whites, colors, and delicates
Cons:
Slow to dissolve
Only available in two scents
EC30 laundry sheets gained second place for their effective stain-removing capabilities. From chocolate smears to tomato sauce spills, these sheets eliminated even the most challenging marks from clothes. Their whitening performance was also unmatched and effectively brought back the whiteness of fabrics that impressed our team.
However, it's worth noting that the EC30 swatches were slow to dissolve, even in hot water. During our tests, we observed noticeable chunks floating in water even after more than 5 minutes of agitation. In comparison, other brands' sheets dissolved much faster, ranging from 2 seconds to 2 minutes. While there was no remnants of the detergent sheets in the washing machine after the cleaning cycle, this may be something to watch out for at home.
Shop EC30 Sheets
3
NORWEX: Great Performer
3
Cleaning Ability: B+
Pros:
Certified Biobased Product
Effective in removing less stubborn stains like ketchup, wine, and syrups.
Dissolves in less than 1 minute
Cons:
Higher cost compared to alternatives
Only available in one scent
Norwex's Laundry Detergent Sheets earned the third-highest overall spot. These sheets exhibited an impressive cleaning and whitening performance on pre-stained gray fabric swatches. Plus, they dissolved in just under 1 minute when used with cold water, providing convenient and efficient usage.
Norwex's Laundry Detergent Sheets are USDA Certified Biobased Products, making them an environmentally conscious choice. While Norwex sheets excelled in removing everyday stains like ketchup and grape juice, they required additional effort to tackle more stubborn stains such as tea and lipstick. It's also important to mention that among the detergent sheets tested, Norwex's strips ranked as the most expensive option.
Shop Norwex Sheets
4
TRU EARTH: Reliable Option
4
Cleaning Ability: B
Pros:
Decent cleaning performance
Great for sensitive skin
Suitable for all machines and temps
Cons:
Left some detergent residue
Website is hard to navigate
From our testing, we learned that Tru Earth Laundry Detergent Sheets performed well on some stains like ketchup, however earned one of the lowest scores for other stains like grass and tea. However, we found that these sheets sometimes left a residue on our swatches which is something you might want to look out for.
The instructions on the package were easy to follow and our team did appreciate the fact that the sheets may be great for those with sensitive skin due to their hypoallergenic formulation.
Shop Tru Earth Sheets
Why Our Team Chose Frey As The Number 1 Pick
After evaluating 14 different sheets brands, our team selected Frey Laundry Detergent Sheets as our number one pick. Several reasons drove our decision, making Frey stand out from the competition.
Cleaning Performance: First and foremost, Frey Laundry Detergent Sheets demonstrated exceptional cleaning performance across a wide range of stains. Our comprehensive testing process involved challenging stains such as coffee, red wine, grass, and grease, and Freddie consistently outperformed its counterparts in removing these stubborn marks. Its powerful formula effectively penetrated fabrics, leaving them remarkably clean and fresh.
Whitening Power: In addition to its outstanding stain-removal capabilities, Frey Laundry Detergent Sheets exhibited exceptional whitening power. Pre-stained fabric swatches were subjected to Frey's cleaning process, and the results were impressive. Frey successfully restored the original whiteness of the fabrics, eliminating discoloration and revitalizing the appearance of even heavily soiled items.
User-Friendliness: Frey Laundry Detergent Sheets provided clear and user-friendly instructions on their labels, along with necessary safety precautions. This attention to detail demonstrated their commitment to consumer satisfaction and safety. Moreover, Frey's commitment to environmental responsibility was evident, with their sheets being free from unnecessary fillers and harsh chemicals, making them eco-friendly and gentle on fabrics.
Amazing Scents: Another notable aspect that contributed to Frey Laundry Detergent Sheets being our number one pick is the variety of scent options available. Frey wants to make laundry day more magical and understands that people have unique preferences when it comes to fragrance. That’s why they offer three distinct scents: Bergamot Beach, Cedar Grove, and Jasmine Meadow. Plus, for individuals with sensitivities to fragrance or prefer to avoid added fragrances, they also offer Fragrance Free. The uniqueness in their scent profile and how delightful and fresh smelling their sheets are made the laundry experience a more delightful and memorable experience.
Price Tag: In addition to its outstanding cleaning performance, clean ingredients, and aromatic scents, Frey also offers an appealing pricing advantage with options as low as $0.25/load which is very cost effective when compared to other laundry detergent sheet brands.
Consumer Feedback: Lastly, the positive customer feedback and reviews we received about Frey Laundry Detergent Sheets further solidified our decision. Customers praised the convenience, effectiveness, and unique scents that Frey provided, making it a top choice for many households.
In conclusion, Frey Laundry Detergent Sheets emerged as our number one pick due to its exceptional cleaning performance, impressive stain removal and whitening capabilities, user friendliness, amazing scents, and positive customer feedback. Frey’s commitment to eco-friendliness, clean ingredients while delivering outstanding results made it the clear frontrunner among detergent sheets on the market.
Shop The Number 1 Pick: Frey Sheets
Below are some frequently asked questions by our readers:
Do Laundry Detergent Sheets really work?
Yes they do.
From our testing we found that some brands like Frey actually clean and remove stains better than both liquid and pod detergent.
Do they work with all washing machines?
Yes, laundry detergent sheets work with all types of washing machines including top loading, front loading, or a high efficiency (HE) machine - they all work.
Are laundry sheets safe for my washing machine?
Yes, they dissolve completely in water, leaving no residue on your clothes or in your machine. They're also formulated to be gentle on fabrics and work in all types of machines, including high-efficiency models.
What water temperature should I use?
Laundry sheets are designed to dissolve and function effectively in any water temperature, hot or cold.
Can I use multiple laundry sheets for a large load?
Yes, if you have a larger or particularly dirty load of laundry, you can use more than one sheet. Check the product instructions for recommendations on how many sheets to use per load size.
Do laundry sheets have a shelf-life?
This varies from brand to brand but usually for about 2 years.
Are laundry sheets safe to use with baby clothes?
Many laundry sheets are free from harsh chemicals, making them safe for baby clothes. Freddie is a good choice for this.
Shop The Number 1 Pick: Frey Sheets
clean&greenliving
2024 Clean & Green Living - All Rights Reserved.
The reviews are based on our editor's subjective assessments and are not guaranteed or endorsed by any external laboratory. The material on this may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, or otherwise used, expect with the prior written permission.